Trend That is Not A Trend: Increase in Typhoons and Hurricanes

The science that CO2 is a greenhouse gas and causes some warming is hard to dispute.  The science that Earth is dominated by net positive feedbacks that increase modest greenhouse gas warming to catastrophic levels is very debatable.  The science that man's CO2 is already causing an increase in violent and severe weather is virtually non-existent.

Seriously, of all the different pieces of the climate debate, the one that is almost always based on pure crap are the frequent media statements linking manmade CO2 to some severe weather event.

For example, Coral Davenport in the New York Times wrote the other day:

As the torrential rains of Typhoon Hagupit flood thePhilippines, driving millions of people from their homes, the Philippine government arrived at a United Nationsclimate change summit meeting on Monday to push hard for a new international deal requiring all nations, including developing countries, to cut their use of fossil fuels.

It is a conscious pivot for the Philippines, one of Asia’s fastest-growing economies. But scientists say the nation is also among the most vulnerable to the impacts of climate change, and the Philippine government says it is suffering too many human and economic losses from the burning of fossil fuels....

A series of scientific reports have linked the burning of fossil fuels with rising sea levels and more powerful typhoons, like those that have battered the island nation.

It is telling that Ms. Davenport did not bother to link or name any of these scientific reports.  Even the IPCC, which many skeptics believe to be exaggerating manmade climate change dangers, refused in its last report to link any current severe weather events with manmade CO2.

Roger Pielke responded today with charts from two different recent studies on typhoon activity in the Phillipines.  Spot the supposed upward manmade trend.  Or not:

kubotachan2009

c2789-wpac-50-10-weinkleetal

 

I am not a huge fan of landfalling cyclonic storm counts because whether they make landfall or not can be totally random and potentially disguise trends.  A better metric is the total energy of cyclonic storms, land-falling or not, where again there is no trend.

Via the Weather Underground, here is Accumulated Cyclonic Energy for the Western Pacific (lower numbers represent fewer cyclonic storms with less total strength):

ace-west-pacific

 

And here, by the way, is the ACE for the whole globe:

 

ace-global

Remember this when you see the next storm inevitably blamed on manmade global warming.  If anything, we are actually in a fairly unprecedented (in the last century and a half) hurricane drought.

  • Mike Powers

    Well, you see, there are more typhoons Tweeted about in the past four years than there were in the previous hundred. It is, therefore, obvious that the number of typhoons has greatly increased in the past four years, because otherwise we would have been Tweeting about them.

  • Mercury

    Even worse: The last hurricane destroyed a $1mm house but this hurricane destroyed the $4mm house built in its place, therefore climate change!

  • wildbill41

    And if by chance there is ANY reversion towards the mean in the future, it will be held as proof of AGW

  • Arrian

    Is there any science on _why_ cyclonic activity is down? And isn't it tornadoes as well as hurricanes/typhoons?

  • marque2

    To the alarmists it is almost as if Typhoons and Hurricanes didn't exist before global warming. Philippines used to have a typhoon hit every few years do to natural forces. Now those same typhoons every few years are only caused by AGW.

  • Matthew Slyfield

    Global Warming. Didn't you know that Global Warming (tm) causes everything?

    On a more serious note, I have read a number of sources that the main source of energy in cyclones is not the temperature of the water beneath them, but the temperature gradient between the equator and the poles. Every warming scenario, be

  • http://itsaboutliberty.com/index.php MNHawk

    "it is suffering too many human and economic losses from the burning of fossil fuels"

    Maybe this journalistic fraud should pay more attention to what's actually going on in the Philippines, as opposed to the dictation she took from an activist. In the real world, the President was just given emergency powers to get as much power (primarily coal) online, as soon as he can, precisely because they would start suffering economic losses if widespread power outages start happening next summer, as currently predicted.