First, I must confess that I have been to opening day of every Star Wars movie, and I have tickets for opening day of this last one. Yes, I am kindof a geek, but no, I am not a total geek: I did not sit up all night in line or anything for these movies.
This is actually a bit of an accomplishment, because I don't think many people saw the original Star Wars movie on the first day. One thing that I think a lot of people don't remember, given all the Star Wars hype and success, is that the original movie opened without much hype or expectations. I was with my family visiting LA, where we were staying in some hotel in Century City (maybe the Century Plaza - I remember it seemed pretty nice). Anyway, my dad was on business and my mom and sisters were shopping so I walked over that morning to see what was playing at the Century City movie theater. It was in that way I accidently saw the first showing on the first day of the original Star Wars. It was me and about 7 other people in that huge theater. I was so blown away that I stayed for a second showing.
Anyway, time passes. Empire Strikes Back was great. I thought at the time that Return of the Jedi was pretty mediocre, but that was before I saw Clone Wars which I thought was visibly stunning but really bad. I cringed every time there was any substantial dialogue, particularly when Padme was on the screen.
Anyway, I take this review pretty seriously, because they seem to have had the same reactions I had to the previous movies. The Good news: visually even more stunning, cool fight scenes, and a better all around movie than the other prequels. The Bad news: the Padme dialog still sucks, maybe even worse.
I really enjoyed watching Revenge of the Sith. And yes, it is quite a good film.
However, the scenes with PadmÃ© alone are enough to give you flashbacks of the
worst parts of the first 2 sequels, and thus lower your overall enjoyment ofthe
Still... it is a strong film with a strong story, great effects and much
improved dialog (with the exception of anything with PadmÃ© in it). Star Wars
fans should be quite happy... and non-Star Wars fans will enjoy as well.
Overall... I give Revenge of the Sith a solid 7 out of
10 (would have been a 9 if they just totally took out PadmÃ© or
re-wrote all her pathetic dialog).
It gets much worse treatment in other venues, but for roughly the same reasons.
UPDATE: Here is my review
Due to the haste with which we are proceding through the
latter phases of this battle-station's construction we have been forced to
employ scores of civilian contractors from across the galaxy in addition to our
own Imperial Corps of Engineers. This had led to a certain clash of working
For instance, this morning I critiqued a tragically sub-par
piece of workmanship on a tractor-beam repulsolift inversion assembly by
snapping the neck of the site supervisor and throwing his limp corpse down a
disused elevator shaft.
Imperial engineers would have snapped to crisp
attention, of course, but all these civilian contractors did was give me was
grief. "Oy, you do that again and I'll have the union on you!" barked one
"It is vital that you enhance the inter-departmental
syngergies of your operation," I said. And then I killed him.
I can relate.